Login

Lost Password?

Create New Account

Navigation

Reviews by slydog

StoryReview
Cursed Love (G)
by Jillian.
Chapters [1]
Reviews [8]
Warnings [None.]
Sun Oct 03, 2004 5:45 pm
that was incredible. i always had sympathy for maeglin only after ur story do i add his anguish over his mother's death. great story. u part telerin?
nerdy joke
 
 
Red Dawn, Golden Flower (PG)
by Viv.
Chapters [1]
Reviews [21]
Warnings [character death]
Thu Apr 01, 2004 11:56 pm
hey....again!
I fully agree. Im actually kindof surprised that u suggested that! your story is best the way u want it to be and u shouldnt change it....but it still would be nice to see some of those BLT details dramatised i.e. idril seeing her father die atop his tower or the last tower of gondolin fall. I think if u want to add more u would have to tweak ur story a bit. but y ruin a good thing? Ur a great writer and obviously knowledgable in tolkien so ... y not write another account altogether? I hope to read more of ur canon stories soon. sorry im writing late but i just got home from spring regatta. secret identity really. drunk by night, tolkien reviewer by later that night!
 
 
Red Dawn, Golden Flower (PG)
by Viv.
Chapters [1]
Reviews [21]
Warnings [character death]
Sat Mar 27, 2004 1:15 pm
Hi
I hope u dont think that i think that ur story was any less touching because of the different role. It was great and i fust wanted to point that out to non fanatics who dont think tolkien gives fighting roles to his women.
Great story...again
 
 
Red Dawn, Golden Flower (PG)
by Viv.
Chapters [1]
Reviews [21]
Warnings [character death]
Thu Mar 25, 2004 6:21 pm
Great story
Tiny gripe
Idril did not have the warrior-like role she had in the book of lost tales.