Reviews for "Echo"

Sat Feb 12, 2005 6:53 pm

This is such a good story, and coming from someone who always wants more, that's saying a lot. Please e mail me as I'm considering this for an award for Best Drabble. Beautifully crafted! So much emotion with so few words! I love the relationship between Boromir and "his" hobbits, Merry and Pippin, especially dear Pippin. Thanks so much for a wonderful drabble.

Wed Mar 02, 2005 12:25 am

I know I already reviewed this... but I was browsing through the things I had already looked at just now and stumbled across this marvellous, poignant, emotional smote to the heart and couldn't help but re-read it again about 10 times. I noticed in the reviews you've received that everyone has supected the room he's in is Boromir's... which is strange, because the first time I read (and then re-read it some more before reading its reviews...and then reading it again afterwards) I have always felt it was *Frodo's* room, and still do. Either person -- it is still lovely, but for me it is more touching if it is Frodo's. : )

Thu Jan 12, 2006 11:23 am

I caught this on the Featured Story, and just had to comment again. I did not remember it, and found that I had already left a comment. Just let me say that it is still beautifully done. Since I did not come in through the archive, I did have to go back and read the description. I wish that it showed up from the Featured Story, as I am left bewildered quite a few times trying to figure things out. LOL This could actually concern several persons. I find that the sign of a well written piece.
Thank you, again, for sharing.

Thu Jun 22, 2006 12:13 pm

It's very hard to read when you have tears in your eyes. Thank you.

Login

Navigation

RSS Feeds

Reviews for "Echo"