Reviews for "Of Falcons and Mûmakil"

Tue Jul 11, 2006 10:24 pm

Lovely story and very well written. Have enjoyed reading this. Found myself reaching the end and going "oh, there's no more, bugger!" Shocked smiley face

Thanks for sharing this story. Well done!

Fri Nov 17, 2006 4:02 am

Delightful! This is excellently written; the content, plot, pacing and flow are superb. I can't wait to read your other stories. *hugs*

Tue Dec 12, 2006 11:39 pm

*just finished chapter six*
Oh, this one is going to be one of my favorites, I can just tell. I got this excited, anticipation about the lead pairing, I love the setting you used, and the supporting characters, and especially the dialogue. It's just amazingly perfect...so far! *keeps reading*

Thu Jan 18, 2007 9:54 pm

Lia,

I did something this week that I very rarely do with fanfiction. I re-read “Of Falcons and Mumakil.” I remember most every story I’ve read (not always a good thing) and think fondly of them, but I’ve only re-read one or two. “Of Falcons and Mumakil” is one of those stories that just drew me in. Over and over, for the past month, scenes from the story kept popping into my head. I decided it was time to come back and read it again.

“Of Falcons and Mumakil” stands up to the scrutiny and high expectations of a second reading. I think it would do equally well with a third or fourth reading. The consistency of your work is astonishing, Lia. This holds true for all of your stories. I don’t make this claim lightly when I say that, in my opinion, you’re the best writer at OSA. I’ve read A LOT of authors here, and there are many great writers, but no one I can think of consistently produces such quality works. There’s something special about your writing that I can’t quite put my finger on, and that’s the way it should be. Every work of art should remain a mystery to the audience, otherwise it’s just a cadaver on display.

I don’t have much time in my insane life (not even enough time for my own stories lately), but I always make sure to follow one story in all my favorite fandoms. It would seem that I’ve latched onto you and your fantastic stories. I have no desire to stop reading about Eomer and Lothiriel, as long you’re writing about them, and follow a different author or different characters for awhile. I think you’re stuck with me now. You would have to ridicule Boromir and call Faramir names in your stories to make me leave you alone.

-Vana

Login

Navigation

RSS Feeds

Reviews for "Of Falcons and Mûmakil"