Reviews for "A Silence Covered in Stone"

Mon Feb 23, 2004 9:48 pm

Nobody's reviewed this yet? I guess the warnings for horror must have scared them off. Smile smiley face

It almost scared *me* off, and it *is* true that the concept of being bricked up like that is highly disturbing (and I'm going to go read something cheerful now), but it was really quite a good story. The only thing I'd say is that I'd love to read more chapters about Thranduil and Celeborn meeting up and clearing out the Greenwood. I was very, very happy when I read in the books that the Lorien folks conquered Dol Goldur--it's always awesome to see a place of darkness overthrown and opened to health and light by people of the light. Good story!

Thu Jul 01, 2004 4:02 am

Another great story! The line about "Why couldn't Elrond send his balrog slayer?" had me cracking up. Having the last King of Gondor still alive was... weird. But I liked it! I liked hearing Thranduil thoughts and feeling, because can simpathize with both sides.

I'll be sure to go read more of your stories! Great job!

Thu Jul 01, 2004 6:14 am

This was awesome. However, I feel I have read it already. It is either part of a larger story, or extremely similar. I am thinking of 'The Battle For The Golden Woods' I think is the name. Did you also write that? It was an awesome story also. Anyway, very well written and enjoyable. That is two of your stories I have read, and I am not disappointed. Thank you.

Thu Sep 23, 2004 3:57 am

I'm sorry about Rous thinking this was part of Battle of the Golden Wood! Yours came first and is better, IMO. In fact they bear very littlel resemblance at all. Still, perhaps I was unconsiously influenced by this - it is the sort of story that stays in the memory for a long time, and one of my favourites. How do I give stars? It ought to have 5.

Sat Mar 31, 2007 12:37 pm

This was very well written. I loved the characterisations of Celeborn and Thranduil and you skillfully built up their relationship with hints of the past and the role of Galadriel in it all.

Login

Navigation

RSS Feeds

Reviews for "A Silence Covered in Stone"