Reviews for "Elanor's Revenge"

Tue Feb 08, 2005 8:44 pm

please, pleas, please write more, this is sooooo good, have been following this story avidly. You write beautifully

Fri Feb 11, 2005 3:05 pm

While I was at first not wild about Elanor, (mostly because when I started this story I had just finished up with Haldir and Amarië - which by the way was fabulous and is on my recommended reading list with this one.) she has grown on me.

I cannot wait until the next update to see how Elanor reacts to a wounded Haldir and I have to admit, I feel a bit sorry for Lurien and hope that you won't trounce on his heart too badly. He seems to really want to be good at heart but just cannot stop himself from trying to get even with Haldir...is that what you were going for?

Well, while you keep me lingering in limbo, I will patiently wait for the next chapters to be posted.

Are they posted yet?

How about now?

Oh, god, just come on.......I'm hooked! HA

Lori Anne

Fri Feb 11, 2005 8:46 pm

I keep passing over this story since I knew it wasn't finished but I read it anyways in a fit of "Haldir Withdrawls." I a hooked and need to know what is going to happen between... well everyone!!

This story is wonderful reading. I neeeeddd MORE!!!

Thu Mar 10, 2005 10:34 pm

This is a great story looking foward to more.

Sat Mar 19, 2005 3:43 am

I was so excited when I got the updated story e-mail that I could not get it copied and pasted fast enough! Well, actually, I freaked out and hit the wrong button, sending AOL into a fit and then had to re-boot the whole system! It was quite impressive really!

I am dying for more and I am sure I can speak for everyone who is involved with this saga, when I say, "WE LOVE VERY LONG CHAPTERS!!!!! The longer the better!!!!!" Very Happy smiley face

You gals are killing me with the torturously slow updates!!! But I do have to admit, they are well worth the wait! Very Happy smiley face

Fri Mar 18, 2005 6:06 pm

So good to have a new chapter - and the promise of another one VERY SOON! Lots of angst this time (sob) so we really deserve that update ...

Fri Mar 18, 2005 7:02 pm

I know that you refer to this as a 'soap opera', and I suppose it might be called that in a way, but the reason I particularly love this is that it brings the world of Lothlorien to life in a very real way, it just shows the every day life of normal elves, and I find it really easy to read and also terribly engaging. The characters of Elanor and Haldir are so well defined and their development or relationship so believeable. I simply can't get enough of this! Your portrayal of Galadriel is perfect, she is shown as both powerful and yet real, even the portrayal of Orophin and Rumil bring their characters to greater life and reality than other fics that I've read.

The only problem is that you don't update soon enough! Beatifully written, please continue (soon Very Happy smiley face

).

Fri Mar 18, 2005 7:26 pm

This story continues to be absolutely delightful to read. All of the characters' situations are so fascinating and wonderful to read about. I look forward to reading more in your next update.

Wonderful job ladies! Very Happy smiley face

Michelle...

Fri Mar 18, 2005 11:31 pm

Poor, poor, POOR Haldir!!!!!!!!!! Bawl smiley face

And poor me too, who got this update when I was still at work and had to wait until evening to read it! I almost went insane... I haven't been on the group lately because real life has caught up with me, sorry Surprised smiley face

ops: But I still read your wonderful work, stop by to read the messages of the group and see how is everybody doing. Anyway, I am already waiting impatiently for the next chapter! You girls rock! Wave smiley face

Sat Mar 19, 2005 12:39 am

This is my favourite story on OSA, I absoloutely love it! Please post next chapter soon as I need my 'fix' of Haldir ASAP !!!!!!!!!!!!

Login

Navigation

RSS Feeds

Reviews for "Elanor's Revenge"