Chapter Two - Strangers of Time and Place
Sons and daughters of the dust
Strangers of time and place
For a while your limbs entwine
Holy marriage of the flesh
But I know your ways
Your ways are not mortal thought
Till the day breaks and shadows run
Run away.
Harvest Moon, C & R MacDonald.
There were three days of deep mourning for the King before his funeral procession. Arwen spent all three days kneeling at the side of her husband’s body, her head on his unmoving chest, some or all of her children and grandchildren with her at all times. Her brothers, Lord Celeborn, and Glorfindel stayed with her all the time, as well, but Legolas had found it impossible to remain in the dim, still, room so full of sorrow; he had gone out into Arwen’s garden after kissing both Aragorn and Arwen on their brows.
He sat now beside the pool and the waterfall that he had designed with her such a long time, and yet such a short time, ago; Gimli, who had made it all work, sat a little way off saying nothing. Legolas heard footsteps approaching – soft but unmistakable; Tindómë. He hoped she would not touch him – he did not think he could bear sympathy now, or he might… she touched him on the arm.
“Atheg,” she said.
He did not move a muscle. She sat down beside him. He should have retreated to one of the trees, rather than sitting here, but that would have left Gimli alone. Tindómë would have climbed after him, anyway. But even as he wished to be alone, to hug his sorrow to himself, yet still he was glad that she had come.
“There is nobody here but you and me,” she said softly. “And Gimli, of course, but he is as much your brother as you are mine.” Her arms came around him and she pulled him, unresisting, around and down until his head was on her shoulder. Her hand stroked down his hair and she said, “You have held me when I’ve wept, atheg…”
Then his tears came – he knew he could have held them back, showed no emotion, remained dignified – but it did not matter any more; he wept silently on Tindómë’s shoulder. Even when he heard heavy footsteps approach he did not move. Gimli’s arm came down onto his shoulder and, although Legolas kept his face turned away from the dwarf, he heard what could only be sniffles; Gimli, too wept for Aragorn.
……………………………..
Over a hundred and twenty years had passed since Tindómë had sat on a balcony of The King’s House, with Rumil and Orophin, and watched people make their way across the courtyard to the crowning of King Elessar of the House of Telcontar.
This was a different balcony, and Orophin was not with them, but the echoes were there. Many mourners were there because they were family; others were officials, foreign ambassadors, or members of the Gondorian aristocracy; they crossed the courtyard beneath the window where Tindómë and Rumil stood. So very much like the crowds who had criss-crossed the space before the coronation. And most of them no more familiar than those faces, then, had been.
But amongst them, unchanging and yet so very changed, she saw Legolas, Elladan, and Elrohir just as they had been at the coronation. Her heart lurched as she saw Gimli, walking beside Legolas, each emotionally supporting the other; but there were no hobbits, no wizard.
Finally, dressed from head to toe in black, heavily veiled, supported by her grandfather and her son, came Arwen.
“Perhaps,” Rumil said, “she thought it best to remain alive to support Eldarion.”
“You think?” Tindómë asked. “She doesn’t look as if she’s supporting him so much as he’s supporting her…”
“Why else would she not have left the circles of the world in the same moments as Aragorn?” her husband asked her.
“I don’t really know – maybe she’ll wait until they are in the House of the Dead, and just lie down beside him, but that seems… horrible. Maybe she’ll come back, and have to put up with people all being sympathetic to her and saying things like how sad they are at her loss, and so on, just to be polite. Then go to her bed and choose to die there. But… I don’t know, I have a bad feeling about it, herven-nín.”
She could feel that Rumil was saddened to see both his current and his former Lord so sorrowful; but also worried, just as she was. As they stood back from the window he took her in his arms and they stood together, gaining support from each other.
There was a reception in the Great Hall of Feasts – but such a solemn and melancholy event, Tindómë thought, as she stood on the sidelines beside Rumil and, mostly, people-watched. So many joyous occasions they had attended in this place, over the years, as Rumil recorded naming ceremonies and, later, the marriages of Arwen and Aragorn’s children. Today he held no pen or pencil; this was not a scene to take to Arwen’s parents and grandmother.
Almost against her will she found her mind turning to the first time they had gone Starlight Bathing – and Rumil had worn black and dark grey relieved only by silver. Today he wore an almost identical outfit, in keeping with the traditions of Gondor, and his silver blond hair and pale skin glowed against the sombre colours; he was beautiful, this husband of hers.
Inside her head she heard his mental voice. “You are beautiful, too, meleth, even all in black. I would take comfort in sharing our bodies together later. It is a pity, perhaps, that Eriathwen did not come, for I think such comfort would help Legolas also. And he is one ellon that we most certainly could not offer such comfort to.”
It was unusual for a married couple to share their bodies with anyone else – but, for comfort, not totally unknown. But Rumil was right; she totally couldn’t have, not with Legolas. For a second her natural sense of humour shone through the heavy atmosphere of gloom and she found herself ‘saying’, “Well you could. I could go do something else…”
Actually Legolas did join them later, but certainly not in their bed. Whilst Arwen’s kin stayed with her, Legolas and Gimli sought Tindómë and Rumil out, Galanthir with them. No-one tonight cared whether he was supposed to be a servant or not. Anyway, Tindómë found herself thinking, there would probably be few more visits to the court of Minas Tirith now…
The party spent much of the evening listening as Legolas and Gimli reminisced about the first days of the Fellowship; not just the things Aragorn had done, but small moments with the hobbits, memories of Boromir, of Gandalf.
All the time, Galanthir kept topping up wine glasses and pouring mead into a large tankard that Gimli had brought out with him. Eventually, as Rumil joined in with an anecdote about the march to Helm’s Deep, Tindómë found her eye lids drooping but, just as she began to drowse against Rumil’s shoulder, Legolas stood up and signalled to Galanthir. Between them they manoeuvred Gimli to his feet and towards the door back into the building.
For the first time since they arrived in Minas Tirith, Tindómë saw her ‘big brother’ grin. “He never learns…!” he said. “He will sleep well tonight. Galanthir will keep me from melancholy, nethig, Rumil; I will see you at breakfast.”
For a fleeting second Tindómë thought of her comment to Rumil, and of Galanthir keeping Legolas from melancholy… but it was only a fleeting thought, followed by ‘and if so it would be nothing to do with me…’ before deciding that her husband looked very beautiful and he, too, might need comfort after mention of Helm’s Deep.
……………………………..
There was still a sense of unreality about the Citadel; usually Tindómë and Rumil had joined the royal family for breakfast, but it seemed wrong to intrude on Eldarion and his family now. The problem was solved by Galanthir knocking at their door.
“Legolas says to come and join him and Gimli for breakfast. We have asked a maid to bring it to Legolas’ suite. There is no word of the Lady Arwen, and we have not seen Lord Celeborn or Lords Elladan and Elrohir. Legolas tries to hide his grief, for he feels as if he has no right to grieve as they do, but we cannot leave this place, yet, either. Still, he is now occupied dealing with a dwarven hang-over…”
Sure enough, Legolas was plying Gimli with food, Gimli was insisting he was most certainly not hung-over and the gentle bickering was the most normal thing Tindómë had witnessed since the night of the ‘last supper’.
“Do we wait here until Eldarion’s coronation, atheg?” Tindómë asked.
“No. No. I do not think I could stay here that long. Already he has to start meetings with ambassadors, but I think it will be some time before he is crowned. He, too, awaits his mother’s passing as well as mourning his father.”
“Are we going home soon, then?” she ventured to ask.
“I… I think we will stay a little longer; to be here for Elladan and Elrohir when Arwen is forever lost to them. And… I do not think I can bear to be outdoors just today – I fear I might hear the cry of the gulls, nethig.”
She had been kinda expecting that.
“Yeah, well, just tell the gulls that you’ll put them on hold,” she said, reverting to her ‘Valley Sindarin’ partly through stress and, also, because she knew it not only amused Legolas but also made him think about what she’d said.
When the knock came on the door, the five were sitting in companionable silence; Rumil, as often, with paper and a pencil, Gimli likewise, sketching an intricate design for something, and occasionally muttering to himself. Legolas and Galanthir were sitting, heads together, over a piece of wood carving, and Tindómë, with fine wool and needles made by her husband, knitting.
Into this very picture of domesticity, Elladan’s entrance seemed almost alien.
They all turned, barely breathing, expecting him to announce Arwen’s death. Instead he turned weary looking eyes to Tindómë.
“Tithen maethor, would you come with me to Arwen’s chamber? She is asking for you.”
Well, that was pretty unexpected. And he obviously thought it was not going to be an easy visit, or he wouldn’t have called her ‘tithen maethor’…
……………………………..
Arwen was in her private withdrawing room; as Tindómë entered she waved to her to come and sit beside her, and then looked at her brothers. They ushered all the other family members out of the room until only Arwen and Tindómë remained. Arwen was still in black – somehow the black fabric looked darker than her hair – the raven black hair, that had never shown any sign of grey, still didn’t but it had lost all its sheen. Arwen seemed, somehow, smaller, diminished in some way, and the tracks of tears may not have been visible, but her red eyes and puffy cheeks showed clearly that she had shed many.
They sat in silence for a few moments as if neither knew how to begin a conversation where one of them had been expected, by the other, to already be dead. Then both began to speak together. Tindómë deferred to the... Dowager Queen, she realised. Eldarion’s wife might be very old, and frail, but she was, now, Queen of Gondor.
“Tindómë,” Arwen began, “Tinu, I... I need your help... your advice.”
She paused, leaving Tindómë touched by the use of the ‘pet name’, which the twins actually used for both of them, and baffled as to what advice she could be expected to give.
“I... I don’t know how to do it. I don’t know how to die! Estel did not tell me how, but it looked so simple when he did it. I thought, because you used to be mortal, or were at least brought up as a mortal, you could tell me how.”
‘Ai Elbereth! What in the name of all the Valar am I meant to say to that?’ Tindómë thought.
“Uh – to be honest, Arwen, most people I knew when I was part of a mortal family were trying very hard not to die. The way Aragorn did it was – well I don’t think ordinary people can do it like that.”
Arwen nodded slowly. “I have asked Eldarion, and Gilraen, already. Eldarion said he did not know – but expects that he will when the time comes. Gilraen said she will stay for her children and let nature take its course. But, much as I love my children, I do not know just how nature would take its course for me – perhaps I will stay to see not only my children but my grandchildren and great, great, great grandchildren die and Estel’s fëa will have flown far beyond me…”
She looked as if she was about to break into tears again.
This was not an easy subject to broach, Tindómë thought, but no-one else was going to do it, so…
“Most people die because they are ill, or else their body just gets worn out so that their heart simply can’t get the blood around any more and it stops beating. But when people really have had enough of life, and their body is still fit and well, then sometimes they just… kill themselves. Take poison, or,” she thought on her feet, shooting yourself or throwing yourself under a train were not options here, “ uh, cutting their wrists where the blood flows, or, even, throwing themselves from a very great height so that they break everything…”
“I am not sure which poison would work,” Arwen said, “and I am not sure what Eru, or the Valar, think of the other options – for an elf are they the same as kin-slaying?”
“Uh – I don’t think they would be – and you want to be treated like a mortal. But I can see your point; and it’s not good for whoever finds your body, anyway,” Tindómë answered.
She thought a little longer. “Sometimes, when people are so sad that they don’t want to go on, they just stop taking care of themselves. Stop eating, don’t do anything if they get ill, and, then, something that would usually just make them ill for a few days will make them die instead. Except that you wouldn’t get ill. But…”
“It would take me quite a long time,” Arwen said, slowly, “an elf can go for a long time on short rations. But the elfling that you found in Éowyn’s garden had just faded away from lack of food, and the cold weather…”
“And,” Tindómë was beginning to see a rather bleak path ahead, but a path no less, “even though you have chosen mortality perhaps, if you were to allow yourself, you would… well… fade. It would be very sad for your family, but it would surely mean that your fëa would join Aragorn’s.”
“I… I think it is the only way,” Arwen said, sounding, oddly, more positive than she had since Tindómë arrived in Minas Tirith before Aragorn had died. “But,” Arwen continued, “I would not want to stay here. It is not my home, now, and I do not know whether Estel’s fëa is still here waiting for me or has already fled.”
“When mortals choose to simply let themselves ‘fade’ they often do it somewhere where they’ve been happy,” Tindómë suggested, thinking all the time ‘the twins will murder me if they know I’m telling their sister to kill herself by self-neglect, especially when they know the next bit!’
“Perhaps you should go to Imladris… you were happy there together, and Aragorn’s fëa would surely know to look for you there.”
“No.” Arwen’s answer surprised Tindómë, but the Dowager Queen went on, “We spent little time together in Imladris – it was my home, it was his home, but rarely together. No – but there is somewhere that we were both so happy together. He would surely be willing to wait for me there.”
She didn’t say where, though. Instead she stood up and came over to Tindómë and hugged her tightly.
“We will not meet again, Tinu, in this world or beyond it until it is remade. But now I know the path I will take, and I thank you. Please tell my parents I loved them very much, when you meet them – but I loved Estel more.”
She stood back, and then added, “When you see my mother, I want you to hold her, tightly, for me. Promise me?”
‘Meep!’ Tindómë thought, ‘So not the thing to do to a high-ranking elven lady you’ve never met before! But I guess this is sort of a promise to a dying friend, even if she’s dying pretty slowly…’
“I promise,” she said.
“Thank you,” Arwen said. “Thank you for that; and for being willing to talk about dying. Please, ask Elladan and Elrohir to come back.”
And that was it – dismissed. Arwen already looked as if she had almost forgotten Tindómë was there. So she let herself out quietly and did, as requested, find the twins and send them to their sister.
……………………………..
Arwen was right. Neither Tindómë nor Rumil, Legolas, or Gimli saw her again. A little after dawn the next morning Elladan knocked on the door to Tindómë and Rumil’s suite; they were not asleep.
“Arwen has gone,” he said.
“Gone?” Tindómë asked.
“As the first light streaked the sky.”
That still wasn’t helping a lot… “Gone where Elladan?”
“Lothlorien.”
Well that certainly wasn’t what Tindómë had expected.
Rumil, who knew of his wife’s conversation with Arwen, nodded. “They were happy there,” he said, “it is the right place for her. The trees sleep now, but they will awake enough to support her.”
“She would not let us go with her…” Elladan said, his voice sad.
“But?” Tindómë now recognised the slight vocal nuances of all these elves she had come to regard as ‘family’.
“She told Elrohir and I not to follow and she rode out alone. But Grandfather said that she had not forbidden him from following and, even if she had, he is still her grandfather – and he was the Lord of Lothlorien for Ages.
“And then Glorfindel said that he would ride with Grandfather, unless we needed him more. Which,” Elladan finished, “of course we do not.”
He paused. Neither Tindómë nor Rumil spoke – it was difficult to know what to say.
Elladan continued, “Thank you, Tinu, for talking to her yesterday.”
Uh – that wasn’t exactly what Tindómë had expected, either.
“I do not want to know your conversation,” he went on, “but it lifted her from deep despair. Whatever you said helped her to find her way – even if it is a way that I know not, yet, whether I will ever follow.”
Tindómë felt as if he had kicked her in the stomach. And there was nothing she could say, even if she wanted to scream ‘No! Don’t you even think of not sailing! Don’t think for one moment of choosing mortality!’ Telling him to totally abandon all thoughts of even seeing Arwen in the afterlife, within hours of her heading off to die, was so not in the best possible taste.
Rumil knew, of course, how she felt. She could feel his love wrapping around her and hear his silent voice in her head. "They may not come when we sail, meleth, but surely they will come eventually.”
She hoped he was right.
……………………………..
‘tithen maethor’ - little warrior. The twins gave her this nickname not long after she ‘arrived’ in Middle Earth.
……………………………..
AUTHOR'S NOTE; If you want to know what Galanthir did to 'Keep Legolas from melancholy' you can read it HERE; http://www.tthfanfic.org/Story-23510-9/curiouslywombat+For+Small+Returns.htm
Disclaimer as chapter one.


