[Sirannon]

And now to revive an old topic.

1) Idril
2)Faramir (book version only)
3)Elros
4)Glorfindel
5)Galadriel
6)Aragorn
7)Gandalf
8 Merry
9)Finrod
10)Bilbo

[Eruanna]

My favourites?



1. Beleg Cuthalion (The ORIGINAL marchward stud, just read the "Lays")
2. Haldir (movie and book, Mr. Parker...)
3. Eowyn (gutsy gal warrior)
4. Elrond (wise and in love with Celebrian, happily married)
5. Galadriel (the most powerful elf of the Third Age)
6. Beren (loved Luthien so much)
7. Luthien (loved by Beren)
8. Celebrimbor (suffered for the Rings, died a horrible death, his body became a banner for the evil ones)
9. Gandalf (Why not? The good wizard!)
10. Maedhros (I feel sorry he lost his hand)

LOL!

--Eruanna

[RoxieRxChicago]

Hmmmm...Let's see...

1. Haldir
2. The Twins
3. Glorfindel (both the first and second edition)
4. Arwen
5. Aragorn
6. Eowyn
7. Elrond
8. Feanor
9. Beleg
10. Tuor

[Tylany]

Oooh my turn!
1. Orophin
2. Rumil
3. Haldir
4. Elrohir
5. Glorfindel
6.Legolas
7. Elladan
8. Thrainduil
9. Erestor
10. Lindir
*gurgle gurgle wait wrong one Tylany drowned in my drool never to be heard of again.*

No, I come back because PEFs have three lives! See that how we special!

[Alassante]

[Rhapsody]

[FallingIntoStrangers]

I am just gonna stick with five mmm'kay?

5. Arwen (So little is known about her really. I would like to have seen more of her in the books)

4. Elrond ( I gotta know about his life story in detail for some odd reason)

3. Faramir (So why come in the book he's the only one <except Tom Bomb> that scoffed at the ring and didn't care for it, it makes no sense...)

2. Aragorn (I think a whole book should be written of his exploits of his whole life BEFORE he shows up in FOTR)

1. Gandalf (C'mon, it's a given, what's his life story, being a demi-god and all kinds of questions) He is hands down my fave character in the book.

[RoxieRxChicago]

Which twins?... I would say Amrod and Amras, and Elladan and Elrohir, but that would really be cheating wouldn't it... So I'll have to go with the Peredhil twins... I'm more partial to brunets than redheads

[Rhapsody]

10.. just ten?

1. Maglor
2. Bilbo
3. Beleg Cuthalion
4. Isildur
5. Imrahil
6. Éomer
7. Faramir
8. Halbarad (or any rugged ranger for that matter )
9. Elladan
10. Éowyn

Now where do I leave Gloryfindel?

[RobinKa]

1. Beleg
1. Haldir









3. Aragorn
4. Glorfindel
5. Maeglin
6. Fëanor
7. Beren
8. Aredhel
9. Thingol
10. Gandalf

[ghettoelleth]

Good lord, who the hell dragged this old rattlesnake outta the cellar? Hehe, sure is fun reading the transition from, don't fart sideways or prepare to defend yourself to the death to, I'm sorry, you can't possibly be serious. As Marty and Bobbi Mohan-Culp would say, good times, people, good times.

To Write:

1. Glorfindel
2. Caranthir
3. Maeglin
4. Osse
5. Haldir
6. Cirdan
7. Orophin
8. Gildor

In General:

1. Maeglin (Like my tortured boys)
2. Feanor (Such power and arrogance, could he really have been so utterly void of remorse?)
3. Caranthir (Kind of like a build-it-yourself Feanor. Just love this dude)
4. Hurin (My latest interest, what a sucky deal this guy got. He was crapped on more than Job.)
5. Voronwe (of Gondolin, not Gondor.)
6. Gil-Galad (Whose feckin' father was Fingon!)
7. Eomer (My first ever favorite character of Tolkien's from the first time I read the books at 13)
8. Gwindor (shhh)
9. Glorfindel
10. Cirdan