[Alassante]

Okay based on the ever changing fan fiction scene, I am wondering who is hawt now? So give me your idea on who is in this week?

Whose has a higher "hawt" factor?

1) Elladan vs. Elrohir
2) Witch King vs. King of the Dead
3) Haldir vs. Legolas
4) Nazgul vs Balrog
5) Eomer vs. Faramir
6) Aragorn vs Boromir
7) Eowyn vs. Arwen
8 ) Frodo vs Sam
9) First age elves vs Third age elves
10) Isildur vs Ar-Pharazôn
11) Celeborn vs. Thranduil
12) Elrond vs. Finrod
13) Twin sons of Elrond vs Twin sons of Feanor
14) Orophin vs. Rumil
15) Morgoth vs Sauron
16) Galadriel vs. Luthien
17) Glorfindel (first age) vs.Glorfindel (third age) - sorry he is too hawt to compete against anyone but himself
18 ) Merry vs Pippin
19) Gimli vs. Thorin Oakenshield
20) Prince Imrahil vs. Prince Theodred
21) Denenthor vs. Theoden
22) Celebrimbor vs. Maedhros
23) Maeglin vs Feanor
24) Gollum vs. Smeagol
25) Ecthelion vs. Fingolfin


Many thanks to Viv, my partner in crime on this.

[Alassante]

My Votes:

[SpaceWeavil]

I got as far as #19.

1) Elladan vs. Elrohir

Both together obviously would be hawtest.

2) Witch King vs. King of the Dead

Probably the Witch King, if we’re talking ‘post-mortem’, since he at least didn’t have like bones and stuff showing. Sorry but I have an inherent phobia of skeletons that would just get in the way of any hawtness

3) Haldir vs. Legolas

Haldir, probably. Legolas does nothing for me.

4) Nazgul vs Balrog

Nazgûls. Balrogs are more like cute fluffy pets. Unless by Nazgûl you mean fell beasts, in which case they’re both cute fluffy pets IMO. If that’s the case then Balrogs would probably be hottest…literally

5) Eomer vs. Faramir

Oh, Éomer. Never really could take to Faramir.

6) Aragorn vs Boromir

Boromir, I reckon. Has that little edge of fallibility about him, plus he wins on the hygiene stakes.

7) Eowyn vs. Arwen

Not really into girls, but I would say on strength of personality, probably Éowyn.

8 ) Frodo vs Sam

Neither. Used to like Sam in the books, but movie! Sam and Frodo just annoyed me.

9) First age elves vs Third age elves

I’m more a Second Age gal, personally, but out of those two, I’d say First.

10) Isildur vs Ar-Pharazôn

I might be a bit sick for this, but I’d reckon Ar-Pharazon. He has that whole ‘Hammer Horror’ evil leader thing going for him.

11) Celeborn vs. Thranduil

Toughie. I like them both. But I reckon Thranduil would probably win out on hawtness stakes.

12) Elrond vs. Finrod

Do you have to ask me this one?

13) Twin sons of Elrond vs Twin sons of Feanor

See answer to 1. Applies to both options.

14) Orophin vs. Rumil

Neither. Don’t like them much.

15) Morgoth vs Sauron

I’ve read too much slash fiction to find Morgoth anything but squicky right now. So probably Sauron.

16) Galadriel vs. Luthien

Oh, Gladdy, definitely. I mean, Luthien was pretty and could dance, but what else?

17) Glorfindel (first age) vs.Glorfindel (third age) - sorry he is too hawt to compete against anyone but himself

Not a Glorfindel person really, but I imagine he was at his hottest when he met the Balrog…sorry, I do apologise for that. Couldn’t resist.

18 ) Merry vs Pippin

No idea. I think I prefer Pippin personally

19) Gimli vs. Thorin Oakenshield

No idea, as I’ve never really had a firm image of Thorin in my head.

[SpaceWeavil]

Sorry Al, didn't see your second post till I'd posted mine. Looking at it, yours is a slightly more space-saving way of replying

[VanatheEverYoung]

1) Elrohir
2) Witch King
3) Haldir vs. Legolas--Damn, only #3 and I'm stumped. TIE!
4) Nazgul
5) Faramir
6) Aragorn
7) Arwen
8 ) Frodo
9) First age elves vs Third age elves--Another TIE!
10) Isildur
11) Celeborn vs. Thranduil--Damn you Alassante!!!! Fine, Thranduil.
12) Finrod
13) Twin sons of Elrond
14) Rumil
15) Sauron
16) Galadriel
17) Glorfindel (first age)
18 ) Merry
19) Gimli vs. Thorin Oakenshield--ugh!
20) Prince Imrahil
21) Theoden
22) Maedhros
23) Feanor
24) Gollum vs. Smeagol--WTF?
25) Fingolfin

[inglor]

[RobinKa]

1) Elrohir (because I liked your Elrohir avvie, Al )
2) Witch King
3) Haldir (I agree with Space)
4) Balrog (I agree with Inglor)
5) Eomer
6) Aragorn
7) Eowyn
8 ) Frodo
9) First age elves
10) Isildur
11) Thranduil
12) Finrod
13) Twin sons of Feanor
14) Orophin vs. Rumil (I would say Haldir... I agree with Space)
15) Morgoth
16) Luthien
17) Glorfindel (first age)
18 ) Merry
19) Gimli
20)
21) Denethor
22) Maedhros
23) Feanor
24) Gollum
25) Fingolfin

[TrissMarigold]

1) Elladan vs. Elrohir -I realy can't decide with those two...
2) Witch King
3) Legolas
4) Nazgul
5) Eomer
6) Boromir
7) Eowyn
8 ) Frodo
9) First age elves
10) Ar-Pharazôn
11) Celeborn
12) Finrod
13) Twin sons of Elrond
14) Rumil (based on fanon)
15) Sauron
16) Galadriel
17) Glorfindel (first age) vs.Glorfindel (third age) - sorry he is too hawt to compete against anyone but himself Oh, I agree there. first age
18 ) Merry
19) Gimli
20) Prince Imrahil
21) Denethor
22) Maedhros
23) Feanor
24) Smeagol
25) Ecthelion

[LuthienTinuviel]

1) Elladan vs. Elrohir
Elladan? (the twins are identical, how could either of them be hotter than another???)

2) Witch King vs. King of the Dead
Witch King. Can't see a thing, cool factor sure damn ON!!

3) Haldir vs. Legolas
Legolas. Nuff said.

4) Nazgul vs Balrog
Nazgul. Fear vs Fire? I'd say fear wins hands on on the hawt factor...

5) Eomer vs. Faramir
Eomer. He gets to be king, plus he's not married yet during LOTR lol.

6) Aragorn vs Boromir
Aragorn. He's still alive.

7) Eowyn vs. Arwen
Eowyn. Warrior chick vs tapestry-making chick.

8 ) Frodo vs Sam
Sam. On loyalty alone.

9) First age elves vs Third age elves
First age. They've still wonder in their eyes (and probably easily swayed by a few *cough* ladies of not the same species hehe...)

10) Isildur vs Ar-Pharazôn
Dunno.

11) Celeborn vs. Thranduil
Thranduil. On the basis that we didn't know much about him to begin with.

12) Elrond vs. Finrod
Elrond.

13) Twin sons of Elrond vs Twin sons of Feanor
Erond's sons. They're actually half human.

14) Orophin vs. Rumil
Orophin? It sounds nicer than Rumil.

15) Morgoth vs Sauron
Sauron. Kicks ass for a mere maia.

16) Galadriel vs. Luthien
Luthien. (sue me)

17) Glorfindel (first age) vs.Glorfindel (third age) - sorry he is too hawt to compete against anyone but himself
First age.

18 ) Merry vs Pippin
Pippin. For growing up eventually

19) Gimli vs. Thorin Oakenshield
Gimli, for looking past his prejudices for Legolas.

20) Prince Imrahil vs. Prince Theodred
Theodred. He wasn't married with 3 kids when he died.

21) Denenthor vs. Theoden
Theoden.

22) Celebrimbor vs. Maedhros
Celebrimbor.

23) Maeglin vs Feanor
Maeglin, that walking around in woe for all eternity sounds somewhat romantic.

24) Gollum vs. Smeagol
Gollum, for being silly over a ring to his death.

25) Ecthelion vs. Fingolfin
Fingolfin.

Oh, btw... *gives inglor chocolate for the suppotive to Luthien bit*

[ghettoelleth]

1) Elladan vs. Elrohir Figwit's more manly in the movies
2) Witch King vs. King of the Dead Mouth of Sauron (sexay!)
3) Haldir vs. Legolas Aren't they couple?
4) Nazgul vs Balrog Nazgul dude, they're invisible, they can get you free stuff at the pharmacy.
5) Eomer vs. Faramir Aren't they a couple?
6) Aragorn vs Boromir They were a couple.
7) Eowyn vs. Arwen Both dead, killed by mass murdering author
8 ) Frodo vs Sam Well, they USED to be a couple
9) First age elves vs Third age elves There were elves in the 3rd age?
10) Isildur vs Ar-Pharazôn Ew
11) Celeborn vs. Thranduil Thranduil
12) Elrond vs. Finrod Puhleeeeeez Finrod
13) Twin sons of Elrond vs Twin sons of Feanor again, Puhleez Ambarussa
14) Orophin vs. Rumil Use to be Orophin, Ish is changing my mind
15) Morgoth vs Sauron Morgoth's may be ugly, but at least he's got two eyes, then again, I got a thing for Gorthaur's mouth.
16) Galadriel vs. Luthien Pfft, Galadriel
17) Glorfindel (first age) vs.Glorfindel (third age) Now I know they're a couple
18 ) Merry vs Pippin Pippin has better kronik
19) Gimli vs. Thorin Oakenshield Gimli "The Thud Man" Gloin's boy
20) Prince Imrahil vs. Prince Theodred Theodred's dead
21) Denenthor vs. Theoden Even dead, Theoden's teh hawtness
22) Celebrimbor vs. Maedhros HUH???
23) Maeglin vs Feanor Maeglin's annoying me right now which is why I'm doing this inane crap
24) Gollum vs. Smeagol Gollum, I love an anorexic man
25) Ecthelion vs. Fingolfin FINGOLFIN, all Ecthelion did was land under a balrog.

Gee Ghetto, this must be national piss off the world day...

[Silvae]

1) Elladan vs. Elrohir - They're twins! (?!) Elrohir based on fanfic personality
2) Witch King vs. King of the Dead - King of Dead. Am not a fan of snufflers
3) Haldir vs. Legolas - Legolas.
4) Nazgul vs Balrog - Balrog. See 2)
5) Eomer vs. Faramir - Eomer, definitely. Faramir a bit too passive (and did you see his NOSE in the movie?! - oops. *ducks*)
6) Aragorn vs Boromir - Aragorn w/ dirty hair
7) Eowyn vs. Arwen - I agree! Warrior princess vs. untouchable porcelain perfection incarnate?! Nuff said
8 ) Frodo vs Sam - is this a HAWTNESS survey?
9) First age elves vs Third age elves - T.A. Elves.
10) Isildur vs Ar-Pharazôn. Oh, Ar-Pharazôn, def. Isildur was a bit of a freak.
11) Celeborn vs. Thranduil - Thranduil; he's more interesting.
12) Elrond vs. Finrod. - Finrod
13) Twin sons of Elrond vs Twin sons of Feanor - Feanor's!!
14) Orophin vs. Rumil - Don't like'em either
15) Morgoth vs Sauron - Sauron!
16) Galadriel vs. Luthien - Over-ambitious Seer or Prancy Perfect (yet brave, I admit) Luthien? Galadriel!
17) Glorfindel (first age) vs.Glorfindel (third age) - sorry he is too hawt to compete against anyone but himself - F.A. Glorfindel
18 ) Merry vs Pippin - Merry.
19) Gimli vs. Thorin Oakenshield - ?! See nb 8. Gimli's less of a jerk, though.
20) Prince Imrahil vs. Prince Theodred - Imrahil!
21) Denenthor vs. Theoden - Denethor had more of a presence.
22) Celebrimbor vs. Maedhros - Celebrimbor
23) Maeglin vs Feanor - Maeglin (heehee)
24) Gollum vs. Smeagol - Gollum is... cute.
25) Ecthelion vs. Fingolfin - Fingolfin

[mistressofbucklebury]

1) Elladan vs. Elrohir... can I have both!?!
2) Witch King vs. King of the Dead. The Witch King... I've read "The Cursed Queen of Angmar", nuff said.
3) Haldir vs. Legolas... blonde pretty boy elves are just not my style
4) Nazgul vs Balrog. Balrog... he's hot and he's got a whip
5) Eomer vs. Faramir. Eomer... wouldn't mind a roll in the hay with him!
6) Aragorn vs Boromir. Like you even have to ask! Boromir
7) Eowyn vs. Arwen. Eowyn gotta give the sister some credit.
8 ) Frodo vs Sam. I refuse to answer that they both have hairy feet
9) First age elves vs Third age elves. First age elves... they knew how to have some fun
10) Isildur vs Ar-Pharazôn. Isildur... I've got a thing for tortued bad boys
11) Celeborn vs. Thranduil. Thranduil just because
12) Elrond vs. Finrod. Finrod.. he was high king for Arda's sake
13) Twin sons of Elrond vs Twin sons of Feanor. Again can I have both!!!!
14) Orophin vs. Rumil. See question 3
15) Morgoth vs Sauron: Sauron cos he makes pretty jewellry
16) Galadriel vs. Luthien. LUTHIEN the girl kicks ass!!!
17) Glorfindel (first age) vs.Glorfindel (third age) - sorry he is too hawt to compete against anyone but himself... I ask again can I PLEASE have both!
18 ) Merry vs Pippin: see question 8
19) Gimli vs. Thorin Oakenshield. Gimli he likes beer meat and starts drinking games... he'd be great at a party
20) Prince Imrahil vs. Prince Theodred. Theodred (pre-death, anything else would just be squicky)
21) Denenthor vs. Theoden: Theoden, he's got the whole sexy older guy thing going on
22) Celebrimbor vs. Maedhros. Celbrimbor... see question 15
23) Maeglin vs Feanor. It's a toughy but I'd say Maeglin... his Daddy's just a little to scarily obsessive for my tastes
24) Gollum vs. Smeagol. Hell No even I have some standards
25) Ecthelion vs. Fingolfin. Fingolfin... just cos.

[Silvae]

1) Elladan vs. Elrohir - They're twins! (?!) Elrohir based on fanfic personality
2) Witch King vs. King of the Dead - King of Dead. Am not a fan of snufflers
3) Haldir vs. Legolas - Legolas.
4) Nazgul vs Balrog - Balrog. See 2)
5) Eomer vs. Faramir - Eomer, definitely. Faramir a bit too passive (and did you see his NOSE in the movie?! - oops. *ducks*)
6) Aragorn vs Boromir - Aragorn w/ dirty hair
7) Eowyn vs. Arwen - I agree! Warrior princess vs. untouchable porcelain perfection incarnate?! Nuff said
8 ) Frodo vs Sam - is this a HAWTNESS survey?
9) First age elves vs Third age elves - T.A. Elves.
10) Isildur vs Ar-Pharazôn. Oh, Ar-Pharazôn, def. Isildur was a bit of a freak.
11) Celeborn vs. Thranduil - Thranduil; he's more interesting.
12) Elrond vs. Finrod. - Finrod
13) Twin sons of Elrond vs Twin sons of Feanor - Feanor's!!
14) Orophin vs. Rumil - Don't like'em either
15) Morgoth vs Sauron - Sauron!
16) Galadriel vs. Luthien - Over-ambitious Seer or Prancy Perfect (yet brave, I admit) Luthien? Galadriel!
17) Glorfindel (first age) vs.Glorfindel (third age) - sorry he is too hawt to compete against anyone but himself - F.A. Glorfindel
18 ) Merry vs Pippin - Merry.
19) Gimli vs. Thorin Oakenshield - ?! See nb 8. Gimli's less of a jerk, though.
20) Prince Imrahil vs. Prince Theodred - Imrahil!
21) Denenthor vs. Theoden - Denethor had more of a presence.
22) Celebrimbor vs. Maedhros - Celebrimbor
23) Maeglin vs Feanor - Maeglin (heehee)
24) Gollum vs. Smeagol - Gollum is... cute.
25) Ecthelion vs. Fingolfin - Fingolfin

[Shanalir]

OK, I'll give it a shot.....

1) Elladan vs. Elrohir - I agree, Elrohir based on fanfic personality

2) Witch King vs. King of the Dead - Witch King, invisible, but not quite a ghost

3) Haldir vs. Legolas - Haldir, something about bulky muscles....

4) Nazgul vs Balrog - Balrog, I agree, what could be hotter?

5) Eomer vs. Faramir - Eomer, he's so nicely touseled

6) Aragorn vs Boromir - No real pref, but I'll go with Aragorn, since he lived

7) Eowyn vs. Arwen - Eowyn, she killed the Witch King

8 ) Frodo vs Sam - Again, no real pref, but I'll go with Sam, he's not such a pretty boy

9) First age elves vs Third age elves - No pref, elves are hawt no matter what

10) Isildur vs Ar-Pharazôn - ? Isildur since I have some foggy notion of who exactly he was (I really need to get my books back)

11) Celeborn vs. Thranduil - Thranduil, gotta love the air of mystery

12) Elrond vs. Finrod - Elrond, see #10

13) Twin sons of Elrond vs Twin sons of Feanor - Twin Sons of Elrond

14) Orophin vs. Rumil - Rumil, he was a redhead (OK, strawberry blonde) in the movie and I always had a thing for redheads, plus he's the more funloving of the two in fanfic

15) Morgoth vs Sauron - neither, theyre both creepy

16) Galadriel vs. Luthien - Galadriel, since she resisted the call of the ring ( wonder if Luthien could have)

17) Glorfindel (first age) vs.Glorfindel (third age) - sorry he is too hawt to compete against anyone but himself - Third age, he dies in the first.

18 ) Merry vs Pippin - Pip's cuter

19) Gimli vs. Thorin Oakenshield - Gimli, anyone who could overcome centuries of predjudice to call an elf a friend gets major points on the hawtness scale IMO

20) Prince Imrahil vs. Prince Theodred - Theodred, just because I like his name better

21) Denenthor vs. Theoden - Theoden, gotta love that Arthurian attitude

22) Celebrimbor vs. Maedhros - Celebrimbor, a smith has gotta be pretty bulky (see #3)

23) Maeglin vs Feanor - Feanor, see #10

24) Gollum vs. Smeagol - Neither one does anything for me

25) Ecthelion vs. Fingolfin - ? Fingolfin since it's a nicer name, again, see #10

I think I need to do some major reading up, and find me a copy of the Silm.

[Ves]

I just love this subject.....



1) Elladan vs. Elrohir

Hey gotta love them both


2) Witch King vs. King of the Dead

Witch King is much more frightening to me. I like the King of the Dead because he does end up doing the right thing by helping out Aragon. The Witch King is just plain Evil.....

3) Haldir vs. Legolas
Movie wise.... I love Haldir because he is just plain bad to the bone.

4) Nazgul vs Balrog

Nazgul because they looks so hot in their costumes. Bookwise, Balrog is hotter because he is much stronger and a more formidable enemy.

5) Eomer vs. Faramir
Eomer..... I am not a big Faramir fan.

6) Aragorn vs Boromir

Aragorn.....

7) Eowyn vs. Arwen

Eowyn, because she is the go to girl she is a true warrior. While still being a strong love interest. I like Arwen because she is like a rock ... she never looses hope.

8 ) Frodo vs Sam
Sam, I love him in the books. Frodo was kinda of snobby.

9) First age elves vs Third age elves
Both......hehheh

10) Isildur vs Ar-Pharazôn
Ar-Pharazon was much cooler...

11) Celeborn vs. Thranduil
Thranduil is pretty hot with his crown that changew with the seasons....
12) Elrond vs. Finrod
Elrond


13) Twin sons of Elrond vs Twin sons of Feanor
Twin sons for Elrond..

14) Orophin vs. Rumil
Easy one OROPHIN........ I love him...

15) Morgoth vs Sauron
Morgoth

16) Galadriel vs. Luthien
Both

17) Glorfindel (first age) vs.Glorfindel (third age) - sorry he is too hawt to compete against anyone but himself
First age.....

18 ) Merry vs Pippin
Both

19) Gimli vs. Thorin Oakenshield
Gimili

20) Prince Imrahil vs. Prince Theodred
Prince Theodred..

21) Denenthor vs. Theoden
Theoden.

22) Celebrimbor vs. Maedhros

Celebrimbor... I mean he did make the three rings....
23) Maeglin vs Feanor

No opinion really.

24) Gollum vs. Smeagol
Neither

25) Ecthelion vs. Fingolfin
Fingolfin.[/b]