Reviews by inglor

How I Spent My Summer Vacation · Wed Jun 15, 2005 2:41 pm

Nice fun read. This is one of the best Marysue Parodies I've read. Delightfully irreverent. Loved the attitude.

Now imagine all the stuff she could get done w/ 1st Age Elves: Feanor: New blinbling, Finrod could install a nice tile floor, Ecthelion: a nice fountain for the patio, I bet Eol could make her some first rate kitchen knives...

Fell Beast III: Fluffy's First Flight · Thu Jun 09, 2005 11:20 am

You do have a way with punch lines

Paradox of the Fourth Age · Wed Jun 01, 2005 1:20 pm

RE Ch 3 (the second one after the Prologue)

Again, Wow.

Oh No he didn't go THERE...

You have a real talent for showing very strong emotions, forcing the reader into the heads of the character. Actually felt some of the horror described. I hate your writing, always leaves me in a bad mood and tense, makes me want to go break something. Very Happy smiley face

The confrontations were masterful.

Now I've swallowed the damned hook.

Paradox of the Fourth Age · Tue May 31, 2005 12:23 pm

As Thuriniel said, Very Original. (Seems like a lot of effort to justify a MS Razz smiley face

, I'm KIDDING.)

What impresses me most about this it the build up of tension. Also, I like your effort at a logical flow of events after things go wrong , not using "Because I said so!"

Not one but several "Wow's" with this one. It is pure joy when you can't see things coming and they smack you in the face, leaving the reader with a big fulfilled grin plastered on their face

I'm hooked

Morning Encounters · Tue May 31, 2005 11:03 am

ditto

*Snort*

The End of All Things · Wed May 25, 2005 2:33 pm

Well done. You captured the desparation and resignation perfectly.

I think you got it right.

Fionnabhair · Tue May 17, 2005 2:18 pm

Viv said
> I could argue with you for whole minutes that Galadriel was the most realized character in Tolkien's opus, but that would be ultimately boring. Smile smiley face

This piece was chatty yet academic, unexpected yet not rambling, clear yet complex. Although you spend a fair amount of time discussing Arwen and Eowyn (to good effect), the main point seems to be that LoTR is most approporiately described as an epic, rather than a novel. I buy the argument, but I was expecting something slightly different when I clicked on the story title.
<

My thoughts exactly, including the Galadriel comment. And I liked your reference that LotR leaves so much fertile ground for Fanfics as opposed to "The Classics".

However, one must read the Sil and UT to have that opinion. Which brings me to my only dig, the fact that LotR was a small part of a much larger work. The foregrounding is in the Sil. So much so that I would suggest reading the Sil (and UT) before reading LotR.

You nailed it that it should be read with the mind set of one reading the Illiad and not *insert Great Novel title here*.

"Eighteen Hours In Minas Tirith" · Tue May 17, 2005 10:53 am

Read it again and... makes me want to go kiss my wife. romance at its finest

Thanks again,

Inglor

Mairisuweniel Does Minas Tirith · Fri May 06, 2005 10:50 am

You have the best one liners. Like Letters, this one has little jabbs that make me howl.

BTW, Bendy Luthien: Banana smiley face

Inglor

Galadriel's Shots · Fri May 06, 2005 10:38 am

That was a hoot. ALL POWERFULL ELF QUEEN is schitzo, very clever twist. Bet this was fun to write, giggled the whole time didn't you? I did reading it.

Inglor

Login

Navigation

RSS Feeds

Reviews by inglor