Reviews by littlecorinthian

Okay, NOW Panic! · Sun Sep 14, 2008 3:50 am

Oh goodness, I can't believe it's over! :0(

WOW! This has been such a fun fic- well, pair of fics, to read (I actually re-read through Don't Panic yesterday on a whim- I had forgotten about Lindir's 'River Incident'! Love it!). I love how it all came full circle. Oh, what a great story! :0) I've greatly enjoyed this foray into Penny's adventures, and I look forward to any outtakes that may come (I bet Penny and Halladan with their kids could provide some pretty funny one-shots). You've created such a fun little world within Middle Earth, I'm sad we won't get to 'visit' it anymore!

Thank you so much for a wonderful few years of Penny's tale. I wish you all the best on future writing exploits (and life in general :0P) and can't wait to see what you come up with next!

(Oh, and for the record, my vote is some outtakes with Lindir and maybe Rhimlath. Or Arvain. I'd happily beg for some childhood Arvain :0P)

Okay, NOW Panic! · Wed Sep 10, 2008 9:32 pm

Yaaaaay!!!! :0) Oh, I was hoping that was what you were leading up to and I'm so excited! Happy dance for both Penny and Halladan! :0P

Wonderful chapter, I can't wait (even more than usual) to read more!!

Okay, NOW Panic! · Sun Sep 07, 2008 1:21 pm

No lynching, but oh man!! :0) Every time I get the 'update' e-mail for this story, I do a mini-happy dance in my chair. And now I can't WAIT to get the next one! Wonderful job once more- I can't wait to find out what happens next!! :0)

Okay, NOW Panic! · Mon Sep 01, 2008 6:41 pm

Oh, yay- I do the happy update dance! :0) Can't wait for more!

Okay, NOW Panic! · Fri Apr 18, 2008 3:44 pm

Ok, no I can review, after spending the last week and a half getting completely caught up with Penny's adventures. :0) I had read ‘Don't Panic’ and started reading ‘Okay, Now Panic!’ *years* ago, but the last chapter posted had been right after the party first left Imladris for Gondor (I want to say chapter 5 or 6, but I can’t remember), and due to school and the rest of RL, I eventually lost track of them. Needless to say, I was thrilled to discover both stories were posted here on Open Scrolls.

I also wanted to take a moment and tell you that, on top of a well-written and highly entertaining story (I would love to see both Lindir and Tadion in action), Penny's tales have really helped me re-discover my love of both the LotR stories, and Middle Earth in general. Not only is your knowledge of canon extensive, but the steps you’ve taken to apply that to how a normal 21st-century woman would react to it is really fantastic (I have to say, Penny’s reaction to Edoras reminded me in vivid detail of my experiences at the Jorvik Viking museum. Good LORD, could I relate :0D). The amount of research you've done and detail you write with is absolutely incredible, and to be applauded. I'm sure Tolkien would be impressed :0) I wish I could say you've inspired me to once again try to read the books, but after several failed attempts to get through even Fellowship (most while in the midst of the high point of my LotR obsession :0D), I think I'll have to content myself with stories like yours to make Middle Earth all the more real for me.

So yeah. There’s my epic review. I’ll content myself that it’s for 50+ chapters.

Thank you again for such a wonderful adventure. It's so much fun to go 'behind the scenes', as it were, especially with someone like Penny. :0) Brava, and I can't wait for more!!!

Lothiriel's Journal · Fri Aug 17, 2007 5:28 pm

Once again, you've created another gem of a fic :0P Fantastic job!!

A Dream Come True · Wed Aug 15, 2007 3:33 pm

Ha! I love it! :0) Of all the Eomer/Lothiriel meetings I've read, this is by far one of the cutest. And always nice to know Lothiriel can hold her own against a drunken king :0P Very nice job!

By the Sea · Mon Jul 09, 2007 9:24 pm

Well, it's been almost two years, but I finally found my way to this fic again- and found a new chapter to boot! Yes, I may be a year late on that front, but still, it made me happy :0P I hope you haven't abandoned this fic, as it's such an interesting take on the Éomer/Lothíriel relationship, not to mention incredibly well written. :0P Very nice job once more, I look forward to more!!

Bound by Duty · Mon Jul 09, 2007 2:23 pm

I just spent the last two days reading this fic, and I had to tell you what an enjoying tale it was! It's been probably a year since I last read LotR fic, and this was a great one to come back in on. Wonderful job!!

Rider of the Mark · Sat Oct 21, 2006 5:50 pm

I would pay good money to go to a wedding like that. :0P Hilarious, fantastic as always, looking forward to reading more!

Login

Navigation

RSS Feeds

Reviews by littlecorinthian