Reviews by RobinKa

Spring Kiss · Fri Oct 07, 2005 12:07 pm

A very tasteful, steamy and extra hobbity fic Smile smiley face

Love it. I'll echo others by saying I admire your writing style, the characters are lovable and extremely well written. Very Happy smiley face

Thanks
Binka

Memories of old · Fri Oct 07, 2005 11:33 am

A very impressive start Smile smiley face

I really enjoyed these two chapters. Very well written. I like your writing style. Good job, Neni Very Happy smiley face

I'll be watching this.

Thanks
Binka

Fallen Leaves · Thu Oct 06, 2005 9:46 am

Did I mention that I love your Gimli? I believe I told you this in private and of course it's worth saying aloud Wink smiley face

Your Gimli is such a compelling character. Thumb smiley face

He's a good, caring friend to Legolas, and he appreciates the Galadhrim sacrifice even though he didn't like Haldir.
Bravo, my dear. Eagerly looking forward to reading the final chapter. Very Happy smiley face

Fallen Leaves · Wed Oct 05, 2005 1:30 am

I'm so glad you decided to post this here Smile smiley face

because I really like your story. Firstly it's a vivid portrayal of how poeple feel after such a battle. What a horrible picture, especially for children. I like the way you introduced Legolas and gave us a heart-wrenching insight into his thoughts and feelings.

Ah, my fav warden... Just Crying or Very sad smiley face

Need a tissue Crying or Very sad smiley face

Thanks for sharing.
Binka

Little Stars · Thu Sep 29, 2005 12:55 am

Space, this was an exquisite gap-filler, short and moving. When I read the Silm, I usually regret that some events, tales, characters are only mentioned without further details. Your ficlet was a brilliant example how a splendid writer could be inspired by a discussion on the forum and turn it into a vivid picture of tragedy. Thank you for sharing.

Binka

The Trees Remember · Wed Sep 21, 2005 1:06 am

What is the greater value among the Eldar? A joyful life with one whom you love? Or a dusty document in Tirion called Laws and Customs of the Eldar?

Wave smiley face

*let it be a comment for the scene*

I loved Haldir's musings in the bathroom Smile smiley face

by the way.
There's so much more to this chapter. I guess you wouldn't be Vana if you didn't stir up danger in the end of it Wink smiley face

and left your readers without a cliffhanger. I liked the way you ended this. It made me very curious and wonder what would happen to Legolas and others and of course Haldir and Elaneth. Bravo! Eagerly looking forward to reading the next installment.

Thanks
Binka

Paradox of the Fourth Age · Fri Sep 16, 2005 8:34 am

I admit I found this particular sentence the most impactful:
Laurëanna could not stay separated from her parents for long, or they from her.

Now, she was alone in the most dangerous world, surrounded by people she could trust, but she couldn't be sure whether they'd trust her. Since the previous update I've been wondering just how Aragorn and other heroes of the past would react seeing Laurëanna and what she would tell them. She found herself in such a difficult situation; she had to convince them but she couldn't say much. By the way, I loved her interaction with Gimli. Also, I was glad to see Gandalf. He's IMO one of characters that makes me think that everything will be just fine.

Eagerly looking forward to the next chapter.

Binka

The Trees Remember · Fri Aug 26, 2005 2:22 am

It's good to know a helping hand is on its way Very Happy smiley face

I like the way you introduced Colin and his father is this chapter. As for the stranger, Hmmm smiley face

I'd vote for Gandalf, but well, I might be wrong. After all I'm only a mere human Wink smiley face

Thanks
Binka

I will never leave you · Fri Aug 26, 2005 1:21 am

This was sweet and romantic. I liked the way you portrayed Maedhros and it made me feel sorry for him. Very well done Very Happy smiley face

Celeborn and Galadriel Speak...sort-of · Thu Aug 25, 2005 1:20 pm

"Understanding": Such a lovely glimpse at Celeborn Very Happy smiley face

I loved the reference to Thingol.
Another excellent drabble. Keep'em coming.

Thanks
Binka

Login

Navigation

RSS Feeds

Reviews by RobinKa