Reviews by Elentari

Don't Panic! · Sun Mar 28, 2004 8:47 am

The endging was really heartbreaking. I was crying like a *baby* when I finished reading...
The selected title is really funny. Hehehe... shoudl have played more attention to the forum, I did not see the voting... sniff. Anyway, Halbarad was, as usual, a very sensitive, wise and kind man. We're all gonna miss him lots. I'm looking forward for the 'wedding of the age' and all other things that happen with Penny, mostly because I love her now and I really want to know that everything ends all right for her.
Thank you so much. It's been an amazing trip. Wave smiley face

All Shall Love Me and Despair · Thu Mar 25, 2004 8:44 am

the only thing I regret about this fic is that's short. However, the mastery in which you wrote Celeborn makes up to it- I can't help myself when I see him well drawn.
Yes, I can see galadriel keeping her things for herself even if she knew that Celeborn would know right away. Very Happy smiley face

A great piece.

Rainy Days · Thu Mar 25, 2004 8:37 am

Absolutely adorable. Both main characters are well drawn, and it captivates us from the beginning. It shows very well how close Thranduil and Legolas are.

Wave smiley face

Spring Awakenings · Wed Mar 24, 2004 11:19 am

I'm rather glad to see you posted this story here... And what a story! the one we have all been holding our breaths for for soooo long!
Eilian is as adorable as can be, as usual. And I loved to see Legolas' way with children... *starts daydreaming* He was really amazing with Rodion.
Whgilst I appreciate parents wishing the best for their children, I still want to strangle Sólith for keeping celuwen adn Eilian apart. That was utterly mean and not very commendable of his character at all.
In short, a long-expected fic, and masterfully drawn too. Very Happy smiley face

Scenes from a life · Wed Mar 24, 2004 11:15 am

Hmmm... while I have to agree that the heroine seems a tad emotionally disconnected at first, and we do not see her bearing any suffering from the loss of her former lovers, you did improve loads while the story progressed. The last three chapters were particularly captivating. If you could develop a tad more legolas' irritation about delaying a important task to go off seeking one of his father's conquers, it'd be fabulous.
For a moment, it seemed to me Eadhild would stay with erestor. It was really a surprise that Thranduil is the one constant in the decade or so that the story covers. And it is really something for us poor mortal women to boast that the 'mortal' was the one to finally figure out the way to the king's heart... take it, Elf-maids! Bah!

Don't Panic! · Tue Mar 23, 2004 8:26 am

To sequel. Definitely. I am really worrying myself mad whether you'll kill Halbarad or not Bawl smiley face

Well, he said he had sons... Twisted Evil smiley face

Am I totally perverted, or just a little twisted? whatever.
This chapter was simply flawless. thank you for putting so much effort. We all love you!

The Cursed Queen of Angmar · Sun Mar 21, 2004 7:33 am

Bloody hell! girl , that was amazing. (I'm still bouncing on my chair, but that's irrelevant, right? Very Happy smiley face

)
Nice, nice Witch king scene. It sort of reminds me of all those action movies when the good guy comes in at the last possible minute. Only the Good guy is usually jumping in with no chances of getting out and the WK is the WK.
Damn, that was great.
Wave smiley face

Beyond Adversity · Sat Mar 13, 2004 2:00 pm

Dearest!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I am overjoyed to review this piece. And we've been waiting for it, haven't we, since you delivered that delicious morsel and left us hanging around, our hearts in our hands....
I am speechless and absolutely thrilled. The prologue was very fine- full of emotion and suspense. Bless you! I am looking forward to see what twisted ideas you have for us.

First Love · Sat Mar 13, 2004 1:46 pm

I have to confess, I nearly fell off my chair. girl, that was bold!
Actually, there are three versions of the tale of Galadriel and Celeborn in the Unfinished Tales. One of them having Celeborn as a Telerin prince, born in Valinor who followed Galadriel into exile, so you're not that far from the track. Tolkien revised himself so many times that a good deal of his mythos are open to interpretation. yummy!
Erestor as galadriel's lover was a nice pick. He would have a character and position much like Celeborn himself- wise, practical, down-to-earth and very at ease with dealing with others more powertful than him. I applaud the choice. The story itself was adorable, in every detail. I greatly enjoyed it.

The Cursed Queen of Angmar · Thu Feb 26, 2004 12:46 pm

I am so absurdly happy!
Thank you ever sooo much, Kazad, for another brilliant chapter. The way that the Witch king comes back into the tale is fantastic. And the Turabar ghost was simply... sniff. I'm sorry i don't have your descriptive skills, but that comes the closest to what I felt. So touching.
And the Witch King CRIED!!! I'm still on cloud nine over that one. the scene was so natural, from his sneaky appearance, to his humour at her anxiousness and his emotions about her near suicide... Bloody brilliant.
Love you. Seriously.

Login

Navigation

RSS Feeds

Reviews by Elentari