Login

Lost Password?

Create New Account

Navigation

Reviews by NenyaCulariel

StoryReview
Adaptation (G)
by Kate.
Chapters [1]
Reviews [3]
Mon Feb 23, 2004 9:55 pm
Oh, lovely story. I am glad someone wrote up this scene. Your dialogue between Legolas and Gimli, and Legolas's inner thoughts, are awesome and very appropriate for the situation. It's always neat when someone in these tales is alive when they were thought dead, but it hurts just as much before you know they're alive! I think you blended movie-Legolas and book-Legolas nicely in this story. The dialogue and tone makes it sound like someone from the books, which makes it easier to take it seriously. Very nice....
 
 
A Silence Covered in Stone (PG-13)
by Zimraphel.
Chapters [2]
Reviews [5]
Warnings [character death; horror; intense claustrophobia]
Mon Feb 23, 2004 9:48 pm
Nobody's reviewed this yet? I guess the warnings for horror must have scared them off. Smile smiley face It almost scared *me* off, and it *is* true that the concept of being bricked up like that is highly disturbing (and I'm going to go read something cheerful now), but it was really quite a good story. The only thing I'd say is that I'd love to read more chapters about Thranduil and Celeborn meeting up and clearing out the Greenwood. I was very, very happy when I read in the books that the Lorien folks conquered Dol Goldur--it's always awesome to see a place of darkness overthrown and opened to health and light by people of the light. Good story!
 
 
There is No Soap in Ladros (PG)
by Halfwest.
Chapters [1]
Reviews [4]
Mon Feb 23, 2004 8:18 pm
Ahahaha! Very Happy smiley face Very funny. I enjoyed your purposeful over-use of flowery and long-winded language. The story *sounded* like strawberry shampoo and spray-on perfume! And I sort of understand where he's coming from, having been introduced to some of the more exotic feminine toilette products rather late in my life. They can be so confusing, even for a girl! Maybe this is one of the nightmares Sauron tormented Gorlim with? Cool smiley face At any rate, this was a story very worthy of bearing the name "humour" and "light fluff". A !

--Nenya