Reviews by RunnerBeast

In Aragorn's Safekeeping · Sat Jun 18, 2005 2:52 pm

Wow - your battle scenes are incredible! Fun, fun! This has been a wonderful way to get another great perspective and view on the books. I'm totally enjoying your OC's... What is going to happen? Please don't kill them off! Bow smiley face

- runnerbeast Carrot smiley face

Forever Yours · Thu May 05, 2005 5:00 pm

I'm really enjoying this. I usually don't like stories with elflings, but this has really captured my interest and my heart. You write really well, I can't wait to read more! Very Happy smiley face

Scenes from a life · Sun Jan 16, 2005 12:50 am

I thought this was really good. I really liked your OC, Eadhild. Considering the hurt she suffered by the rejection by her husband and her desire for freedom, I can understand her reactions to her intimate encounters with the elves. Also later on she connected with many of them, actually all the ones you name here in your story.

My favorite elves that Eadhild encountered are Orophin, he just seems to start her out right. Also, Erestor just because I never thought much about him and I LOVE how you wrote him. I like how she connected with Haldir, but I didn't really feel that spark... dang, I wish she would have been there when he came back that one time for her. I like Thranduil, too, mainly because he provided the stability, financial support and totally appreciation of HER for that time in her life. I loved that Rumil helped her so dearly through that difficult time, and it was very sad when she realized she was never going to see him again. That was very cool to have that part in your story.

This was lots of fun, and there was lots of adventure. Eadhild was able to travel all of Middle-Earth thanks to the elves whether they came to her or they brought her to them. And all the lovemaking was very, very hot. Very well written for sure! I'm glad your story was brought to my attention. Very Happy smiley face

- runnerbeast (J)

Winter Fire · Mon Dec 20, 2004 6:23 pm

This is the BEST dang story! I'm just freakin' impressed here. You have written the most beautiful and wonderfully plotted out Tolkien love story. Great job!
... runnerbeast
You rock smiley face

The Phoenix's Griffin · Fri Dec 17, 2004 3:02 pm

OMG! This was the best story!!! I totally loved this story! It was just gripping. The history of the Rohme, not to mention the OC's Amaras and Phaila was fascinating. I haven't read your other stories yet so I thought this story stood well on it's. You really brought out the visuals well, the beauty of the court, Phaila's home, and the horror of the battles. I love also how you characterized Haldir, he was very strong, yet I really felt for him during this journey.

Is this the very end of this story? Is there an epilogue? I would love to read of Amaras' and Phaila's reunion, and Haldir getting home. I've put this story on my watched stories just in case. =)

You are a wonderful writer. Thank you for this memorable read! I will be watching for more stories from you! Very Happy smiley face

In Aragorn's Safekeeping · Mon Nov 22, 2004 4:34 am

I'm loving your story! I've been glued from the beginning and now that they have made it to elf territory - hey what can I say?! Very Happy smiley face

You have incredible writing skill and your grasp on Tolkien book canon is refreshing! I love your original characters, and so look forward to seeing what happens next in there amazing adventure. Thank you for a wonderful read!
- J

"Mysterious Fate" · Tue Nov 09, 2004 1:24 pm

I'm totally loving your story. I started reading it and stayed glued all the way through. Now I've been longing for the last two beautiful up dates. Yay! Finally I leave a much deserved review. This is a cruel cliff hanger, but I guess I'll live... Kaitlyn did. Wink smiley face

You are a great writer. Lucky me for finding YOU!

Login

Navigation

RSS Feeds

Reviews by RunnerBeast