Reviews by nienor

By the Sea · Sun Nov 20, 2005 3:40 pm

I tend to side with Saccopelista: HIT HIM! Wink smiley face

No, seriously, I think this state is slightly better than the child-like he was in.

I wonder what will happen in Dol Amroth!

Perhaps you could try to send one of the Maiar after your boss, but they are probably hard to come by these days.

Get better from the flu soon, and update, please!

nienor Smile smiley face

By the Sea · Sun Nov 13, 2005 7:15 pm

Surprise indeed!

I am glad that Eomer will not be seen by all of Dol Amroth and probably a great part of the Gondorian court in his child-like state. This would embarrass him so much when he is well again.

However, the state he is in now promises interesting consequences. I wonder what he will do to the poor soul who tells him that he is married. And what when he learns that Theodred, Theoden and a great part of the Riders of the Mark are dead?

Good that you are going to update so soon!

nienor

In Aragorn's Safekeeping · Mon Nov 07, 2005 6:55 pm

Took a while until I had finished. The long chapters are great, of course, but with real life I must see when I have time to read.

Thanks for your e-mail! It is sad to see this fic coming to an end, but I will surely look out for more writing from you.

What I like especially about this fic is that you are very careful to let each character react differently when they are sad or otherwise troubled and so on. Makes it very realistic.

All the best to you! nienor

Suspicions · Sat Nov 05, 2005 7:01 pm

That's good. Very uncommon, but in a good way.

I agree with Diddler07: For being new in the fandom, you got this really well.

If you write more, I'll read! Smile smiley face

Nienor

By the Sea · Thu Nov 03, 2005 4:55 pm

That was close, really. I hope that Elfhelm really leaves, for what might happen if he didn't?

And travelling with a child-Eomer will surely not be fun.

But I fear more and more that he will be terribly embarrassed when he "wakes up". I hope you have mercy on him soon! Wink smiley face

All the best, nienor

By the Sea · Sun Oct 30, 2005 12:51 pm

A chapter, great! Smile smiley face

I'm glad to see that this fic is going on, as I desperately wanted to see how it ends.

The tension between Lothiriel and Elfhelm is so well written, and it is a very unusual setting.

What of poor Eomer? If he comes back to normal some time, he will be so dreadfully embarassed of having been like this.

Thanks for updating, all the best to you!

nienor

In Aragorn's Safekeeping · Wed Oct 12, 2005 6:12 am

Good chapter! I am glad that they made this decision. Smile smiley face

Their reactions to what Gandalf told them were very realistic. The scene made me really sad.
I hope this story continues for a while. Will we see more of the orphaned children?

Greetings, Nienor

Could Will Have Its Way · Mon Oct 10, 2005 4:50 am

I had never thought that Finduilas' death might have been such a great motivation for Denethor to look into the Stone, but now I think you are right. Poor Denethor!

And great drabble. Smile smiley face

Where did I put my pipe? · Mon Oct 10, 2005 4:46 am

Ha, I like this! Addiction, indeed. Makes me think of the commentary of the excended DVD where they said that to be PC they wanted to have him eat sweets instead of smoking in the movies. Honestly.

Well, he is grumpy indeed, but I imagine that's what he would feel like. Well done! Smile smiley face

In Aragorn's Safekeeping · Sun Sep 25, 2005 7:10 am

I've finally caught up with this fic and just wanted to drop in to tell you that I really enjoy it. I think that it's the first girl/boy dropped into M-e fic that really works. The way you had them find their way into the storyline is really convincing, and it's good that you stayed as close to canon as possible. I also like the long chapters.
And now I'm waiting for an explanation about this map Wink smiley face

.

Greetings! nienor

Login

Navigation

RSS Feeds

Reviews by nienor