Reviews by Saoirse

The Tart…! · Tue Mar 22, 2005 5:49 pm

OoooO! How wickedly..emm delicious! hehe! Wonderful job, you've delineated Merry's not-so-subtle eagerness, and Estella's willful helplessness to her husband's lusts very... tastfully! : )

Looking Back · Sun Mar 20, 2005 9:37 am

'Dare I hope that a better son may forgive a bitter father?'

Ah, yes. So achingly perfect. Wonderful.

The Next Day · Sat Mar 05, 2005 3:34 pm

Thanks Regnet, but I was actually shamelessly using movie-verse in the non-movie verse section with that little detail about the birthday party. LoL. Thank you for reading ^_^

~Saoirse

Echo · Wed Mar 02, 2005 12:25 am

I know I already reviewed this... but I was browsing through the things I had already looked at just now and stumbled across this marvellous, poignant, emotional smote to the heart and couldn't help but re-read it again about 10 times. I noticed in the reviews you've received that everyone has supected the room he's in is Boromir's... which is strange, because the first time I read (and then re-read it some more before reading its reviews...and then reading it again afterwards) I have always felt it was *Frodo's* room, and still do. Either person -- it is still lovely, but for me it is more touching if it is Frodo's. : )

A Tookish Prayer · Mon Feb 28, 2005 2:46 pm

Oh, how tender and lovely and ever-so Pippin-ish. That lad! My, my.... hehe You wrote the devotion between then so nicely, I could feel the love they had for one another, and the faith too. I loved this line:

“They can hear us... Can’t you feel it?” Pippin whispered.

“Yes,” Diamond said. “I can feel it”.

Wonderful! I always personally feel that Diamond and Pippin's marriage was one of the rocky and rather bad sort, but this lovely story has given me a look into what a peaceful life between them would be, and it makes me happy sometimes to see Pippin with such a dear lass who obviously cares for him tremendously (such as in this lovely story Smile smiley face

Most of the time I read fics and Diamond really has no substance to her...there was more to her in this, you wrote her well).

... there was another line, something about Diamond ' never loving any other hobbit more than her Peregrin Took' the way you wrote that made me go 'awww' hehe. And also, I liked the little glipse into Valinor! Unexpected but nice. And also I loved how at the end you squeezed in Merry and Estella, as I can never picture a story about Pippin without it including Merry somehow (and vice versa).

I also just loved the part when Pippin began praying to the Valar! Just lovely! Great job Smile smiley face

~Saoirse

Echo · Wed Jan 19, 2005 4:20 pm

Oh, my. How lovely. I can feel the hollowness there... the quietness. Poor Pip, he'll have to learn to accept it.

Conflicting Wishes · Mon Jan 10, 2005 7:21 pm

Oh, my. How very real, I am sure that what you said about "wishing it was another's loved one" is very true indeed.

Life in Fandom · Mon Sep 20, 2004 6:40 pm

LMAO. Omg this is great. LoL. Great! What did Aragorn do? LoL I am so amused by this because I always in the back of my mind have all my favorite fandoms living in a place just like this -- which is kind of weird...but what the heck. Lmao, keep up the good work! (I really like how Frodo had OCD about cleaning [ that is just how I imagine him ], and the descriptions of what the other characters are like are just precious)

Remember When It Rained · Thu Aug 26, 2004 6:54 pm

This is very sweet and touching. I especially liked in the end when he called Faramir "silly", it really brought out the kind of older-brother-trying-to-make-everything-okay-for-the-younger-brother aspect of the story. I felt so bad for poor Faramir when he was debating whether or not to admit to being afraid of the thunderstorm! I'm glad that Boromir felt guilty afterwards (shame on you Boromir) and invited Faramir over. I also like how Faramir went to Boromir for comfort (not Denethor or anyone else) when he was frightened, it goes to show the trust and love he had for his older brother, and in the end Boromir promised to protect him now that their mother is gone, just: aww.

Cool Waters · Mon Aug 16, 2004 7:26 pm

Oh, how beautifully agonzing. So poignant and heart-wrenching. I have no words to express my love for this story. It paints such pictures in my mind, that it even inspired me to draw some artwork for it, it was so lovely. It was written poetically, if I should venture to say that, so wonderfully, that I enjoy re-reading it. Thank you for writing this. Again, I don't think I have the right words to say how v. beautiful this was. ~Saoirse

P.S. I actually was not a member here, and after I had read this again today I decided I simply must leave a review, and it said you had to be registered to leave a review! So here I am, and here is this review. So your wonderful fic was the reason for me becoming a member of this lovely community.

Login

Navigation

RSS Feeds

Reviews by Saoirse