Reviews by esmeralda

How Many Years? · Mon May 31, 2004 8:40 am

That was a beautiful story. If you keep it up, you might manage to make me believe that denethor is more than an old madman who's always been unfair to his second son, that would be a revelation ! Laughing smiley face

I've always been a fan of his eldest son , though, and it was nice to see his boyish side for a while...
Great job Wink smiley face

Okay, NOW Panic! · Sun May 09, 2004 4:30 am

As good as I expected it to be... Every time I see that This story has been updated , I just feel like doing the happy dance! And I agree with kvannom, Lindir turns out to be quite the charmer. A huge "thanks" to all those involved in the writing of this story Very Happy smiley face

I can't wait for another update!

Elanor's Revenge · Tue Apr 13, 2004 7:57 am

Hi ladies, I love chapter 18 (I love the whole story actually) the archery competition (especially appreciate the fact that you did not make Elanor win!) and the incredibly hot birthday present Shocked smiley face

Can't wait for you to update!!! Please? Smile smiley face

Oh and who is Rumil's lady??? I hope we'll know soon...

Namaarie, Mellon nin · Tue Apr 13, 2004 5:07 am

Short fic but sweet and sad and hopeful at the same time, thanks!

Okay, NOW Panic! · Mon Apr 12, 2004 3:05 pm

Hi boz, thanks for writing the sequel so soon Razz smiley face

. Great job with halbarad's death and I really liked the remaining Dunedain protecting his body. What else can I say, great as usual, can't wait for you to update Laughing smiley face

esmeralda

Gondor's Grief · Wed Apr 07, 2004 1:03 pm

It's a sad but good poem. Nice to see that Boromir was not a bachelor after all Wink smiley face

I loved don't panic and am now reading my way through your various stories and poems and I must say that with each story I like you more (doesn't if this is proper english but you got my meaning... I hope.)

Don't Panic! · Sun Apr 04, 2004 3:01 pm

Oh NO Halbarad!!! You're evil boz, do you know that? I know it's not your fault, that it would have been wrong to leave him with penny but... Bawl smiley face

Anyway, thanks for the great story and also a big "Thank you" to your betas who did a good job too! Can't wait for the sequel, love the title you chose.
esmeralda

Don't Panic! · Fri Mar 26, 2004 1:18 pm

I agree with Leilana! Sequel, definitely! Please? Rolling Eyes smiley face

Oh, and have I mentionned how I liked this story? Cool smiley face

Don't Panic! · Sun Mar 21, 2004 9:15 am

I love your story. Actually I think it's my favourite in all the fandom (humour category). I can't believe you manage to build up so much tension in the last chapter with basically ten words in Penny's vocabulary! Shocked smiley face

Amazing job, really! Oh, and bonus points for the chapters titles Cool smiley face

To Balrog or not balrog! Laughing smiley face

Suil Vain (Fair Winds) · Sat Feb 07, 2004 12:55 pm

Wow, I like the new chapters, especially the scene between Buffy and gimli and the Spike/Giles dialogue. And if you want more reviews, post more chapters!!! I know, I know, not always easy to find inspiration but, hey, promise me you won't drop the story before its end, I would be soo frustrated! Evil or Very Mad smiley face

Login

Navigation

RSS Feeds

Reviews by esmeralda