Reviews by ghettoelleth

"Arwen's Gift" and "The Reaction" · Fri Jun 17, 2005 7:06 am

Bravo first time no longer drabble virgin person!! Wave smiley face

The visuals I got on this of Arwen and Elrond were priceless. Wonderfully wistful drabbles that met the objective very nicely. You did have an extra 'and' in there that you could have turned into a wart, lol, but 'tis only envy speaking, ahhh to have a word to spare. Great job hon!

Grey Havens · Fri Jun 03, 2005 5:41 am

I always look my best to the intoxicated. Me too Gil

DAMMIT!!! Dammit dammit dammit dammit. I'll come back to review this when I've had ample time to stop thinking of ways to slay you! Head bang smiley face

The End of All Things · Wed Jun 01, 2005 6:54 pm

Kat, I never read anyone's review before I write my own so I didn't see what you based the concept on but you have to know that it was an amzing parallel to the story of the Mosada, intended or not. And so very well expressed. I'm always so impressed by the esl writers here. If you get a chance, go on your browser and look up Josephus, Eleazar, the stronghold of Mosada and the Sicarii so you can see how well you matched the tragedies without intending too. pretty good fete there kiddo! Very Happy smiley face

Danse Macabre · Mon May 30, 2005 8:14 pm

OOoh, Steve did good by you Space. Before you send him back, please have a little talk with him? I just got chills from that. Very elegantly stated. Of course, you never disappoint. Wonderfully original and artistic interpretation of the topic, above all else. I've be trying to get images of Feanor doing a quadrille out of my head all week.

Roman Nights · Sun May 29, 2005 7:40 pm

Elves listening to the radio. There's something you don't hear every day. This is very sweetly sensual and I loved the rhythm of the prose. I hope people understand what a wonderful fic this comes from and don't jump to conclusions. Very nice Vana

The End of All Things · Sun May 29, 2005 1:32 pm

OMG, this is absolutely the most brilliant concept for a fan fic I have seen in a long long time. Considering all the controversy surrounding Josephus' retelling of the survivors of Mosada and his natural inclination, being Roman of course, to depict the Sicarii from that perspective, this was briliant. To give Eomer a noble Eleazarean voice and to tell the tale from the perspective of those who are actually on their way to death is just genius. It must have been terribly tempting to take the easy road and tell the tale from the perspecitve of Sauron's army or the 'survivors.' giving yourself more scope to tell the tale. To take the restricting view of Eomer, and a bit of Eowyn which may I add was just added brilliance, and tell a story that actually brought me to tears was masterful. I am impressed beyond words. I literally gasped reading the first paragraph I was so taken aback by the creativity of the concept. Congratulations dear. This is unbelievabley wonderful and trust me, its tragic beauty far out weighs its edgy noir. wow Bow smiley face

Fëanor: The Owner's Guide and Maintenance Manual · Sat May 21, 2005 9:04 am

This had me cracking up, too funny. I haven't read the series you mentioned but if its any where near as funny as yours, I will soon. This is just classic.

Perfect Creation · Fri May 20, 2005 9:45 pm

How wonderful and precious. What a fantastic ending, and so very...Feanorish. Wonderfully done Thu.

Whispers on the Wind · Fri May 20, 2005 9:43 pm

Well Ellie, after I finished laughing about the editing choices, (once again, I lost my mind, I'm so sorry)...
This is still the most stunning portrayal of Earwen I have read. It is absolutely heartbreaking when she recalls her father and brother and the way she describes the horror of knowing that it was her husband's people who were responsible. I think the part that has the most impact, however, is when she talks of the unfairness of being immortal and still having to deal with death, and on such a scale. Poor Earwen, when she lost loved ones, she suffered it was never a small loss. Still made me cry and gave me the chills. Beautifully done.

Hoofin' It · Tue May 17, 2005 1:43 am

Oh my goodness. Paint chips! ROFL smiley face

This is hilarious Emm, and very original. I love the interaction with Arod and the fat ass, LMAO. And Uncle Shadowfax is too droll, as he should be. Poor Arod, what a sham his arrogance ended up being. This was so nice to read.

Login

Navigation

RSS Feeds

Reviews by ghettoelleth