Reviews by Scribe

Laundry Day · Sun Nov 23, 2003 6:51 am

Great story and talk about being a lucky girl! Boromir and Aragorn, my mouth is watering after reading it . Just one questions remains now that this feast for the imagination has been consumed. WHEN'S LEGOLAS COMING INTO IT!

A Ranger's Duty · Tue Sep 23, 2003 10:45 pm

This was really quite lovely. I enjoyed it and liked the foreshadowing. Not to mention the characterizations were very much spot on.

Anglachel · Thu Sep 04, 2003 6:47 pm

An interesting analogy likening his relationship with his sword to that of lovers. I suppose what he does with the weapon is an intimate act. Affecting life by taking it away can be considered deeply personal. I wonder how much of this is really Turin describing the dark mirror of his own soul, the shadow that cloud his mind. Is it the sword he thinks is filled with rage or his own subconsciousness finding expression by way of his perception of the blade.

This has given me food for though.

Debbie Does the Fellowship · Wed Aug 13, 2003 10:48 pm

Right there with you Viv... Bawl smiley face

Great fic though. The only Debbie does anyone that isn't x-rated.

Bill's Evil Plan to Take over the World · Sun Aug 03, 2003 5:58 pm

ROTFLAMO! That was brilliant! The special one better watch out!

Help Him · Tue Jul 01, 2003 10:02 pm

Oh my god

, that was wonderful! Poor Smeagol. I kept hearing that haunting music from Two Towers when I read this and know that I'm not going to be able to watch Return of the King without thinking about your words. Poor Smeagol, someone should have tried to help him...

Love of the Sea · Tue Jul 01, 2003 9:57 pm

Great start, eager to read the rest of it. I hope Imrahil gives those servants hell when he's prince of Dol Amroth Evil or Very Mad smiley face

Watch the Clouds Go Sailing By · Tue Jul 01, 2003 9:35 pm

Kate...where is the rest of it????? Now I'm going to sitting around for god only knows how long waiting for the next part. Great fic by the way. Love Gold, although I feel for poor Lily. Isn't there some rich guy with a club foot that will marry her or something? Anyhow, waiting for next part with anticipation. Very Happy smiley face

The virtues of reading the books · Tue Jul 01, 2003 9:19 pm

I don't believe your tone is derogatory because I can understand where you're coming from. Last night I was told of story involving Aragorn, necrophilia, rape, slash and blood play and wanted to know why in the hell someone was writing such a tale when it bears absolutely no resemblance to Aragorn the character. While I have been known to push the envelope and take liberties with the Professor's character, I did so with a modicum of respect to the source material. While I don't take the view of purists that all fan fic must adhere absolutely to what is canon, I do believe you should at least remember why you started writing fan fic about these characters in the first place. Obviously something about them must have impressed you to begin writing in the first place, so why would you completely disregard all those characteristics and infuse them with something so unfamiliar that the character is virtually unrecognisable? I agree with much of what you say, (except the flaming) and believe your essay is relevant to authors who really want to write Tolkien as more than just some fangirl exercise. After all there is a difference between exploring and exploiting the characters and I think your essay has put into perspective some very relevant points. Look forward your next topic and hope to see it here.

The Conversation · Sun Jun 29, 2003 11:00 pm

ROTFLMAO!!!!!!!!

That was so brilliant. "Desk boy!" Talk about conversations you don't want to hear!

Very Happy smiley face

Login

Navigation

RSS Feeds

Reviews by Scribe