Reviews by SilentTears

The Empty Vessel · Sun May 09, 2010 11:28 pm

wow i've been waiting for this chapter. but boy was it worth it, boy was that hot i never thought that ropes could have such appeal but damn haldir has opened my eyes. i'm a perv whatever, very steamy long awaited chapter and i admit i did a double take and ended up reading it again because it was that good.

The Empty Vessel · Sun May 09, 2010 10:53 pm

I really like this story, mind you brawn sorry for the spelling anyway she is kind of a pain and i was excited to see harldir put her in her place. i wanted to shout FINALLY! i mean i know she is suffering and hurting etc but i also felt bad for haldir i mean i didnt see any of his actions as cruel , he didnt go out of his way to be nice and she was always being a pain in the crack to him but i know that her past is the reason why. i was very upset when they were interrupted at the picnic. but overall this is a good story, i've been searching for haldir fiction and have only found a handful of lengthy stories, about 5 to be exact. so to come across your story was refreshing and gave me hope that there are some good Haldir fics out there. thanks for writing this.

The Bond · Wed Dec 16, 2009 6:18 pm

someone on ff.net recommended this story so i am really excited to see how this plays out.

Return to Middle Earth · Sat Jun 04, 2005 1:37 am

Ok where shall i begin? to start off i want to say that this story was freakin incredible, not only was it amazing as far as creativity,mental visualization,humourous and emotiontional involvment between the characters. the relationships between them were more realistic than that of most stories written today. your muse and imagination deserve to be recognised in an honorable fashion. i mean despite the foolishness of elladan the conversations were intelligent, i dont know i just thought this story deserves a 10 on a scale from 1-10. this story has surpased the excellence of Elrohir's Tale, something i thought was imppossile. i do have one criticism. I loathed Sinead with a passion, she was incredibly stupid and annoying. oh i hated her i wanted to write such evil things in here about her but i thought i'd focus on the Brilliance of your story which was everything else aside from Sinead. bravo, bravo i am in dire need of another one of your elven epics.

Nazgul · Thu May 26, 2005 2:49 am

I liked this poem very good and captured alot of elements from the film(or book) cool

Country Side · Fri Sep 10, 2004 5:40 pm

Sorry, I did not give up on this story. My friend wouldnt let me Wink smiley face

but i started college and moved away from home 2 weeks ago so i've been really busy, plus im writing like six stories at the moment however this weekend I am not busy Laughing smiley face

and will write a chapter and try to have it posted by monday-13th. But thanks for the review. by the lack of them I assumed no one was really reading my story so i put this one on hold. but i'll start it up again. Smile smiley face

The Missing Piece · Tue Jul 27, 2004 11:33 pm

That was beautiful. yet sooooo sad. but still beautiful.

New Beginnings · Wed Jun 09, 2004 4:43 pm

Do you have a beta? Because if you need one i'd gladly help you out. I know a few elvish phrases and i could help you. anyway i actually enjoyed this story. There were a few parts that were a little confusing but overall i like it. Finally a story where Haldir isn't acting like an ass.

The Elf in My Closet · Sun Jun 06, 2004 5:15 pm

Hey this is a good story are you going to continue anytime soon

Gone~ · Sat Jan 17, 2004 11:54 pm

Hey i just finished reading the last chapter you posted.. it was really short... but it was good nonetheless... how long ago did u post it? oh well i guess i will sit here bored. waiting for another chapter...Hurry up!!!!!!11 LOL Rolling Eyes smiley face

Login

Navigation

RSS Feeds

Reviews by SilentTears